Today a two-year ban on three insecticides called neonics (neonicotinoids) came into force across the European Union (EU). The neonics are used as seed dressings to reduce pest attacks. Their names are clothianidin, imidacloprid and thiamethoxam.
The neonics have been temporarily banned because they kill bees and other insects that we want to avoid killing. Insects which pollinate crops and which are essential in many other ways, providing ‘ecosystem services’. You could follow my tag ‘neonicotinoid’.
Yesterday Dave Goulson in the Ecologist wrote that this temporary fix isn’t good enough because it doesn’t tackle other problems that good insects face.
Also yesterday, Philip Case in Farmers Weekly wrote that the ban might make things worse because it provides farmers with an incentive to use even ‘dirtier’ pesticides.
Both quite negative, eh? I haven’t yet seen happy buzzing about today’s change in the law as a sweet honeypot. But for bees and other good insects, maybe that’s what it is.
[Edit] Not everybody thinks it’s a sweet honeypot. Many farmers aren’t impressed. Syngenta and Bayer are huge companies who make neonics. They’re taking the European Commission to court about the ban.
I hope it is only a start……
I hope so too. Not convinced that it’s been thought through properly, hence the critiques I link to here, but we’ll see.
It’s so overwhelming… but I am happy to see something is being initiated. Thanks for your always informative posts!
Aw shucks! This one took more research than I’d expected – thought the story would be all over the mainstream news, but it wasn’t. Perhaps it will be.
Reblogged this on Voices and Visions and commented:
The EU bans neonics –pesticides that kill bees…
Thank you for reblogging. I’m going now to follow your blog which looks interesting.
Reblogga detta på Ann Novek–With the Sky as the Ceiling and the Heart Outdoors.
It is a start though – it seems to me that people love to dwell on negative sides of stories. It’s a step in the right direction.
Yes that’s how journalists make money, isn’t it? Whenever there’s an accident, a crime or a demonstration, the story’s about how many people were killed or arrested.
Pingback: Revealed: the chemical blitz bees face in fields | Science on the Land
Pingback: Killing bees in Oregon | Science on the Land
Pingback: Harvard study links pesticides to bee deaths | Science on the Land
Pingback: Real impact of neonicotinoid seed dressings stays buried | Science on the Land
Pingback: TTIP: Syngenta calls for harmonized safety standards | Science on the Land
Pingback: Syngenta withdraws application to use banned pesticide linked to bee harm | Science on the Land
Pingback: A neonic that’s bad news for birds | Science on the Land
Pingback: Neonic makers might pay for research about neonics on the land | Science on the Land