Feeding vegetable oils to farmed salmon

Many fish farmers in temperate climates raise Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). Salmon are carnivores, fed pellets made from (among other things) wild fish. Wild fish are getting scarcer so a team of scientists, led by Erling-Olaf Koppang at the Norwegian Veterinary Institute, is feeding vegetable oils to farmed salmon. A few days ago they published this report of what they’ve found so far.

Why should we care? It’s become standard health advice that we humans should eat plenty of oily fish such as salmon. We’re advised to do this because these fish contain ‘long-chain omega-3 fatty acids’. Awkward name, eh? But salmon tastes good and it does us good.

The trouble is, salmon are carnivores. People catch small wild marine fish containing those health-giving fatty acids. The small fish are then processed into fishmeal and fish oil to make pellets for fish farming (aquaculture). So as we eat more and more farmed fish, we’re exploiting more and more wild fish. This isn’t sustainable.

As small wild fish become overfished, some people are developing the genetically modified (GM, genetically engineered) oilseed crop which I nicknamed Omega Camelina. In that post I linked to a film of Johnathan Napier, who leads the Omega Camelina team, explaining the new GM crop. Prof Napier says that without GM, ‘plant oils can’t substitute for fish oils.’ They don’t have long-chain omega-3 fatty acids. That pretty much destroys the claims about eating plant foods to get those essential nutrients.

But why not feed vegetable oils to farmed salmon, replacing some of the fishmeal and fish oil? Prof Koppang tried feeding oils from olive (Olea europaea), rapeseed (oilseed rape, canola, Brassica napa) and soybean (soya, Glycine max). The salmon grew but their intestines became abnormal. The folds that grow on the inside of fish intestines weren’t so deep in the (partly) veg-fed salmon as they were in the fish-fed salmon.

Folded intestines let salmon absorb nutrients from their feed. This particular study doesn’t tell us whether the (partly) veg-fed salmon grew so fast as other salmon. It doesn’t tell us whether their meat would be equally nutritious to human consumers. If I see answers to those questions, I’ll show them to you.

[Edit] Looking again at the comments on my Omega Camelina post, I see my fellow blogger Kay Hortographical explaining which kinds of vertebrate can convert the short-chain fatty acids found in plants, to the long-chain fatty acids we humans gain by eating salmon. Marine fish can’t do it, if I understand correctly.

But is the Atlantic salmon a marine fish? It spends most of its lifecyle in the sea, but swims up rivers to spawn. So I don’t know whether it can convert short-chain fatty acids into long-chain ones. If it can’t, I predict that when it’s fed vegetable oil its meat won’t be very rich in long-chain fatty acids. If I’m right, the (partly) veg-fed salmon might be cheaper to raise than fish-fed salmon, and more sustainable, but less nutritious for the consumer.


About argylesock

I wrote a PhD about veterinary parasitology so that's the starting point for this blog. But I'm now branching out into other areas of biology and into popular science writing. I'll write here about science that happens in landscapes, particularly farmland, and about science involving interspecific interactions. Datasets and statistics get my attention. Exactly where this blog will lead? That's a journey that I'm on and I hope you'll come with me.
This entry was posted in fish, knowledge transfer and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Feeding vegetable oils to farmed salmon

  1. Littlesundog says:

    Good gracious! I did not know anything about this. I am continually amazed at your research and findings… thanks for keeping us informed.

    • argylesock says:

      You’re very welcome! Esp when I haven’t posted much on my blog here recently.

      I found the article about feeding veg oils to salmon in one of the open-access journals at BioMed Central http://www.biomedcentral.com/ where I’ve automatic alerts set up. My work email often tells me about new articles published in the BMC journals. This one caught my eye because its title (‘Substitution of dietary fish oil with plant oils is associated with shortened mid intestinal folds in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar)’) reminded me about Omega Camelina.

  2. EqFe says:

    You haven’t been posting much, I’m suffering from withdrawal.

  3. EqFe says:

    Most of the time, at least where I live, wild caught salmon is not affordable, at least on my budget. Farm raised is, although it is still more expensive than cheaper cuts of meat, and many other types of seafood. Within reason, anything that lower the cost in the market, I view as a good thing.

    Generally speaking, I’m not a big believer in “superfoods” like wild salmon that are said to have almost magical health benefits, at least by some. I’d rather eat a varied diet, and avoid overly processed and pesticide ridden foods. I have read in the popular press that farm raised salmon already lacks most of the positive health benefits of wild salmon, however, I lean towards a view that the only thing coming out of the ocean that is “sustainable” is farm raised seafood, which is fed vegetable matter.

    • argylesock says:

      I agree that ‘superfood’ claims are mostly nonsense. My favourite example is the goji berry (Asian boxthorn, Lycium spp.) which can seem exotic to W European and N American consumers. It racks up the food miles but it contains no more Vitamin C then the more-familiar blackcurrant (Ribes nigrum).

      What are these alleged ‘positive health benefits of wild salmon’? I’m not saying there are none, and there might be differences in flavour although I find farmed salmon quite delicious. Over here, farmed salmon often bears the approval of the Marine Stewardship Council whose website http://www.msc.org/ explains how that approval is earned.

  4. EqFe says:

    It comes down to lower total fat, a great amount of good fats, and anti oxidents.. http://losebellyfat.com/health-benefits-of-wild-salmon/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s